
I loved Ann of Green Gables, Emily Star, and Pippi Longstocking. I thought it was glamorous to be an orphan. They always had the best adventures.
I anticipated Jennifer Donnelly's
A Northern Light to be in the same vein. It felt similar in the beginning. Girl's mother dies, father is distant, must raise her siblings but she's too smart to be a farm girl. A benevolent teacher shows her opportunity, and you think you know where the book is going. It's nostalgic and comforting, a familiar story. You know she'll struggle between staying with her family and going out into the wide world, but ultimately she'll choose to write or move to the big city or both. But about 1/3 of the way through I realized this story had some interesting twists.
There's a mystery. A dead girl with a mysterious past. It's a plot device that drives the otherwise character centric story, but it doesn't feel like a gimmick. You want to find out what happened to this dead girl, but the whole time you know that it isn't really about this girl, it's about the Matty (the protagonist).
There's a hot boy who wants to feel Matty's boobs and marry her. However, he's not nice. He's sort of charming, but mainly he's dumb. Matty kind of likes him, but she kind of doesn't. And the brilliant part? The part that I respect is that she kind of likes it when he touches her boobs. She is a bit appalled, but she also likes it. And while you're pretty certain how this relationship will turn out, you wonder sometimes.
She is best friends with a guy who is black and it doesn't turn into an interracial romance. there are didactic moments in the book, and her relationship with her best friend is an opportunity to show the racism and violence of the times. But, mainly their relationship is real and smart. They both love words and literature, and their banter is one of the highlights of the book.
While it's certainly not a perfect book, it's a smart next read for young (and oldish) readers who love the orphan sagas; lonely, tough, smart girls with a dangerous need for adventure.